How We Rank Home Service Companies in Canada
Which contractors and service companies make our pages, what sets their order, and what no business can buy.
Maybe it was an ice dam in February, or the spring melt finding a crack in the foundation. Now three quotes on the table disagree by thousands of dollars, and you have to decide who to let in the door. This page shows how the companies on our pages got there. The same rules hold for every city and category we cover, from roofers and renovators to movers, cleaners and realtors, and they begin with one fixed point: no business pays us, so no business can buy a better place.
Who makes the list
We begin with the public listings businesses keep for themselves on maps and search. Every category in every city we cover is searched, and the search is repeated on a regular cycle so new businesses turn up. A business has to pass these checks to appear on our pages, and keep passing them to stay:
- It is still in business. A company marked permanently closed comes off our pages.
- It is a real local company. Call centres and referral networks that pose as a local contractor and pass your request to someone else are not listed, and neither are template websites shared by many unrelated "businesses".
- One branch per brand in each city. A franchise with several locations in Calgary gets one listing there, for its branch with the strongest record. One phone number belongs to one listing only.
- Its website works and is its own. We visit the website each business lists. A dead, parked or taken-over site takes the listing off until it is fixed.
What sets the order
Within a category and city, these points set the order, and no payment or request can change it.
- Customer ratings and how many there are. A 4.7 across 250 reviews tells you more than a perfect 5.0 from three neighbours.
- How complete the profile is. Photos, a website, an email address, opening hours and the details a business states about itself all count, the same way for every business.
- Location. Businesses in the city you searched come first, then businesses in nearby towns, closer ones first. Within each group, the points above set the order.
- Best of holders. Holders of a Best of award are listed first on their own category and city page.
Reviews, facts and badges
Every review on our pages was left by a customer on the company's public listing, in the language the customer wrote it in, often French in Quebec. We do not write reviews or accept reviews sent in by businesses. Some things come out: reviews with profanity are hidden, private details such as a customer's phone number are removed, and anything that is not a review, like an ad or a copied message, is left out. Review counts catch up at the next check.
Profile facts such as warranties, certifications, years in business and services come from the company's own website and are checked against the page they came from before they appear, in French for a Quebec firm whose site is in French. What we cannot confirm is not shown. Badges follow the same rule: licensed, insured or 24/7 emergency service appears only when the company's own site says so and our check of that page confirms it.
We do not verify licences or insurance with the bodies that issue them. Licensing is mostly provincial, so start with your province: in Quebec, the Régie du bâtiment du Québec keeps a public register of licensed contractors, and in Ontario the Electrical Safety Authority licenses electrical contractors. Ask the contractor for proof of liability insurance too, and of workers' compensation coverage, such as a WSIB clearance certificate in Ontario.
What a business can and cannot change
Any business can claim its listing at no cost and correct its own details: hours, phone, services, its description, and a street address it would rather keep private. Changes are checked: a new description against our editorial rules, and a new business name by a person. A business cannot change its reviews or its rating. A complete profile counts the same for every business, whoever filled it in. No payment or request to us moves a business up the list. A company we have not found yet can apply through Join as a Pro, also free.
Best of awards
A Best of award goes to the businesses at the top of a category in a city: five at most, or three where the city has fewer than ten businesses in that category. It cannot be bought or traded for a link or a review. Awards are reviewed on a fixed schedule, and a holder that closes, changes hands or stops earning its award loses it to the next business in line.
How often we check again
Every listing is checked again about every three months, roughly once a season: open or closed, hours, phone, website, reviews and photos. A company that answered its phone in the fall may be gone by the spring melt, and the next check takes it off. If you notice something wrong before then, tell us on our Contact us page. We correct errors as soon as we can confirm them.
Our Independence Policy explains how we are funded, and our Editorial Standards explain how our Canadian home guides are researched and checked.