Best Real Estate Agents in Innisfil, ON

24 firms listed · 4 in Innisfil · 9 open 24/7 · 22 open weekends · 18 rated 4.5+

Data verified October 18, 2026

Shanna McFarlane Real Estate Group

Shanna McFarlane Real Estate Group

(35)
  • Understanding
  • Home
  • Questions
“Because I am not in the country, Shanna did everything from the staging, the photoshoot, the listing, the estate sales and the maintenance of the house while it is being sold all through email and text.”
Transparent Fees & Pricing
RE/MAX Crosstown Realty Inc., Brokerage, 4171 Innisfil Beach Rd #8, Thornton, ON L0L 2N0
i
#1 Team at the Harbour at Friday Harbour

#1 Team at the Harbour at Friday Harbour

(1)
“We appreciated their vast knowledge of this outstanding property and their friendly professionalism at every step in the process.”
Emergency Services
In Business Since 2008
Sea Ray Ave Suite 309, Innisfil, ON L9S 2N4
i
Dwayne Clugston

Dwayne Clugston

(4)
  • Home
“Dwayne helped us get 2 Properties in Huntsville- very good experience and was straightforward, punctual and always ready to show the properties we wanted to see .”
In Business Since 2018
880 Innisfil Beach Rd, Innisfil Beach, ON L9S 2C2
i
Michael Daniel Realty Inc.

Michael Daniel Realty Inc.

Coupons & Offers
1731 Cedar Grove Ave, Innisfil, ON L9S 4K9
i
Frank Burgio Team ~ Sell For 1%

Frank Burgio Team ~ Sell For 1%

(11)
  • Patient
  • Home
  • Market
“Hayden possesses exceptional professional sales skills and the ability to juggle multiple tasks at hand - can't wait to see what the market brings next year!”
2095 Thompson St, Innisfil Beach, ON L9S 1T1
i
Angela Montano Real Estate

Angela Montano Real Estate

(3)
  • Home
  • Questions
“As newcomers, we did not know much about the rental process in Canada but she was always willing to help us understand our rights and the options we had as newcomers.”
Emergency Services
966 Innisfil Beach Rd, Innisfil Beach, ON L9S 2B5
i

The 24 firms listed for Innisfil, ON are brokerages and agents. Their licence claims, the neighbourhoods they name and the property types they handle come from their own websites, with ratings and quotes taken from public reviews.

Area overview: Innisfil, ON

Of the 24 firms we list here, 4 are in Innisfil itself and 20 come from towns including Innisfil Beach (8, 3 km), Barrie (6, 11 km) and Keswick (2, 11 km). 22 of the firms on this page have a rating, from 3.7 to 5.0 across 2,748 reviews; 10 have 50 or more reviews and 18 are rated 4.5 or higher. When customers rate these firms on specific qualities, they most often praise professionalism (95%), responsiveness (89%) and quality (77%). The topics that come up most in reviews of the firms on this page are "price" and "knowledge". 9 are open around the clock; 22 are open on Saturdays and 19 on Sundays. 2 show a licence on their websites. 10 have ten or more years of experience, the longest 27 years. 9 offer emergency call-outs; 2 offer financing or payment plans; 1 gives free estimates and 1 lists coupons or special offers. We have a website on file for 23 of the firms on this page; 16 publish a contact page; 17 list a public email and 2 take bookings online. We count these figures across the firms on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the firm before you book.

How many listed agents publish a website?

A website is listed for 23 of the 24 firms here. Use it to check recent sold listings rather than the profile photo. Look for the brokerage name and licence details, which have to appear on advertising, and for properties sold in the neighbourhoods you care about.

Igor Vujovic

Igor Vujovic

(2)
“Knowledgeable about all aspects of real estate.”
In Business Since 2003
888 Innisfil Beach Rd, Innisfil, ON L9S 2C2
i
Karen Bernard

Karen Bernard

(2)
“Karen is very good and she explained everything to us each step of the way.”
Licensed
2095 Thompson St, Innisfil Beach, ON L9S 1T1
i
Tia Sanginesi

Tia Sanginesi

In Business Since 2012
888 Innisfil Beach Rd, Innisfil Beach, ON L9S 2C2
i
Re/Max Hallmark Chay Group Realty: Dave Moore

Re/Max Hallmark Chay Group Realty: Dave Moore

(5)
  • Home
  • Professional
“He helped us come up with a competitive price, advised us on how to prepare the house for showings and in less than a month had multiple showings and multiple offers.”
2095 Thompson St, Innisfil Beach, ON L9S 1T1
i
Cory Seaman

Cory Seaman

Transparent Fees & Pricing
888 Innisfil Beach Rd, Innisfil Beach, ON L9S 2C2
i
Carriage South Simcoe Real Estate Services Ltd Brokerage

Carriage South Simcoe Real Estate Services Ltd Brokerage

(3)
“Highly recommend to anyone looking to make a relatively stressful event enjoyable and easy!”
31 Queen St, Innisfil, ON L0L 1L0
i
Christie Adams

Christie Adams

In Business Since 2012
888 Innisfil Beach Rd, Innisfil Beach, ON L9S 2C2
i
Century 21 Teamwei.ca

Century 21 Teamwei.ca

(50)
  • Market
  • Questions
  • Goals
“Jessica has probably the best way to show you places and the entire breakdown of the property just send you an email link of couple places here and couple places there amazing company and amazing person”
Free Initial Consultation
Emergency Services
724 The Queensway S, Keswick, ON L4P 4C9
i
The Peggy Hill Team

The Peggy Hill Team

(48)
  • Marketing
  • Stress
  • Home Inspection
“Patient, knowledgeable and endlessly positive - we had a bit of a rough road in a weird market and we couldn't have asked for a better or more supportive person to guide us along and keep us fully informed.”
Transparent Fees & Pricing
In Business Since 2005
Offers Financing Options
374 Huronia Rd, Barrie, ON L4N 8Y9
i
Todd

Todd

(50)
  • Needs
  • Area
  • Housing Market
“There are no words to adequately describe how very pleased we are with the service we received from Todd, Lynn and Jayne Guergis of Royal LePage in Barrie.”
Emergency Services
In Business Since 2005
299 Lakeshore Dr, Barrie, ON L4N 7Y9
i
Parker Coulter Real Estate

Parker Coulter Real Estate

(49)
  • Commission
  • Team
  • Cottage
“I would recommend Parker Coulter Realty to anyone looking to buy or sell their home in Barrie & the surrounding areas who needs an experienced, knowledgeable professional!”
Emergency Services
In Business Since 2016
360 Shanty Bay Rd, Barrie, ON L4M
i
The Trevor Shaw Team

The Trevor Shaw Team

(49)
  • Questions
  • Market
  • Trailer
“He was able to successfully close the sale and was very supportive with documentation for our lawyers and encouragement as the closing was stalled by the buyer.”
Emergency Services
In Business Since 1999
461 Dunlop St W #6, Barrie, ON L4N 9W3
i
Team Metherall

Team Metherall

(50)
  • Know
  • Home
  • Easter Egg Hunt
“She was always available to answer any questions no matter how small, set up viewings and support us through the whole process (which can be challenging in the current market).”
MLS# 38065544
In Business Since 2010
Emergency Services
Offers Financing Options
430 The Queensway S, Keswick, ON L4P
i
Ashley Lamb

Ashley Lamb

(50)
  • The Condo
  • Market
  • Patience
“Absolutely incredible service, from staging advice, to amazing photos and video production, amazing guidance during the deal and their professional approach during the search for my next home.”
Transparent Fees & Pricing
In Business Since 2015
218 Bayfield St, Barrie, ON L4M 3B6
i
The Steven Sarasin Real Estate Team

The Steven Sarasin Real Estate Team

(50)
  • Realtor
  • Questions
  • Needs
“We had very specific goals with our house purchase and she nailed each and every detail and also set up some viewings that weren't on our list for extra ideas.”
Emergency Services
In Business Since 2018
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Serving Innisfil Area
i
Jackie Jones Team

Jackie Jones Team

(50)
  • Realtor
  • Home
  • Patient
“This is how awesome this team is Meaghan Patterson took the time out of her very busy schedule to drop off some sweet treats to myself and Paul Just to say she was thinking about us.”
566 Bryne Dr A, Barrie, ON L4N 9P6
i
Osborne Goddard Team @ Re/Max

Osborne Goddard Team @ Re/Max

(49)
  • Expectations
  • Questions
  • Call of Duty
“Over the last 3 months we have worked with Ian Osborne as our real estate agent: He is truly amazing to work with - Clear, Fast and Honest in all communications.”
Transparent Fees & Pricing
450 Holland St W Unit 4, Bradford, ON L3Z 2A4
i
Jordan Prince

Jordan Prince

(42)
  • Questions
  • Rental
  • Mind
“Time when we couldn't view the property he was able to go and video the property and show us he was there with us every step of the way and I would recommend him to anyone who is looking to own or rent”
Emergency Services
17 Baleberry Cres, East Gwillimbury, ON L9N 0P2
i
HomeRealtorsOntarioInnisfil, ON

Why these companies made our list

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top